Modern use of Dominion Atlantic
-
- Honour Roll 2009
- Posts: 51
- Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2008 4:56 pm
- Location: Clifton N.S.
- stem
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1415
- Joined: Tue Oct 16, 2007 7:19 pm
- Location: St. Albert, Alberta
- Contact:
Re: Modern use of Dominion Atlantic
Not enough space for the whole line would be my conundrum too. Dan came up with a great solution by modelling just the CVR portion.
Myself, I would favour Kentville to Windsor with a Mantua leg in HO to limit the real estate but retaining the busiest section of the D.A.R. for good running. It gives you great industry and a good size yard at both ends. Plus you can share a loop at both ends as both Kentville and Windsor have 2 subs outgoing.
However I would prefer the old Windsor with the bridge across the Avon and running through town. Good for diesels and steam and lots of passenger service and gypsum runs. That would still take a fair chunk but I figure a compressed version is do-able in HO in a 12 x 16 space if you limit freight to 40' and passenger car length to 50' max.
Otherwise it would be N scale. The only problem I have with N is that it just doesn't photograph as well as the larger scales and selection, while being such much better than years ago, is still limited compared to HO. And although not impossible, it's a lot tougher to scratch-build that small.
Myself, I would favour Kentville to Windsor with a Mantua leg in HO to limit the real estate but retaining the busiest section of the D.A.R. for good running. It gives you great industry and a good size yard at both ends. Plus you can share a loop at both ends as both Kentville and Windsor have 2 subs outgoing.
However I would prefer the old Windsor with the bridge across the Avon and running through town. Good for diesels and steam and lots of passenger service and gypsum runs. That would still take a fair chunk but I figure a compressed version is do-able in HO in a 12 x 16 space if you limit freight to 40' and passenger car length to 50' max.
Otherwise it would be N scale. The only problem I have with N is that it just doesn't photograph as well as the larger scales and selection, while being such much better than years ago, is still limited compared to HO. And although not impossible, it's a lot tougher to scratch-build that small.
Steve Meredith
DAR DPI Webmaster and Forum Sysop
DAR DPI Webmaster and Forum Sysop
- Paul Charland
- Charter Member
- Posts: 734
- Joined: Tue Apr 29, 2008 10:22 am
- Location: Brockville, ON
Re: Modern use of Dominion Atlantic
I made a little DAR L shaped switching layout a while back... just an 8 x 4 1/2 footer. My P2K RDC had no trouble negotiating the 18" curve, it was my nice Intermountain covered hoppers that couldn't without the wheels scraping the stirrup steps.
I don't have that problem with V scale!
Paul
I don't have that problem with V scale!
Paul

- stem
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1415
- Joined: Tue Oct 16, 2007 7:19 pm
- Location: St. Albert, Alberta
- Contact:
Re: Modern use of Dominion Atlantic
Cool scan Andrew. Are you still looking for a book all these years later? Samuel has got it scanned but won't release it publicly until the copyright runs out.
Steve Meredith
DAR DPI Webmaster and Forum Sysop
DAR DPI Webmaster and Forum Sysop
-
- Charter Member
- Posts: 329
- Joined: Sat Feb 04, 2012 10:14 pm
- Location: Halifax
Re: Modern use of Dominion Atlantic
The copy right for History of the Dominion Atlantic Railway end in 2017 so another two years! And I've confirmed with CP Rail for the copy right status.
I can send you a digital copy of Clarkes History of the Earliest Railways in Nova Scotia
I can send you a digital copy of Clarkes History of the Earliest Railways in Nova Scotia
_________________
Samuel M Clark
Halifax, Nova Scotia
Samuel M Clark
Halifax, Nova Scotia
- stem
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1415
- Joined: Tue Oct 16, 2007 7:19 pm
- Location: St. Albert, Alberta
- Contact:
Re: Modern use of Dominion Atlantic
It's not like we already don't have enough to do but it would be awesome to OCR it so we could turn it into a searchable PDF.
Steve Meredith
DAR DPI Webmaster and Forum Sysop
DAR DPI Webmaster and Forum Sysop